Skip to main content

Is Saying "It's Not As Good As The Book" Unfair On Movies?

With the release of Ready Player One the phrase "it's not as good as the book" is something I've heard frequently in the last few weeks.  This is even before critics have seen the movie.  Anyway, that's beside the point.  What I want to point out is that it doesn't matter if the book or original content is better than the movie. You should still enjoy both.

Yes, you may be a little disappointed that a certain scene that played out in your imagination thanks to the author's talented way of painting a picture in your mind has been left out of the movie version but, and this is the big question, shouldn't we be taking movies for what they are, a movie?

That sounds pretty obvious but what I'm saying is that movies get a lot of criticism because it's the easy target.  Saying the movie wasn't as good as the book instantly makes the person saying it feel superior.  They read books, that's great.  They knew about the story before the masses went to the cinema and experienced it for the first time, well done.  But movies based on books are generally a two hour window to tell a story that an author has laid out in hundreds of pages of written material.  We should except the medium of movies for being what they are.  I don't want four hour movies.  Damn!  I moan if it comes in over two hours.  It's inevitable that a movie tie-in is going to have missing pieces from the book and generally if you've read the book first then you're going to notice those absent scenes.  Pacing in movies is an important factor and sacrifices have to be made, it's inevitable that scenes will get dropped to make the movie flow.  We should enjoy the fact that we have a version of that book on the big screen.  When we go to see a show based on a book on Broadway or the West End, we don't expect to see everything as we have a preconception of format we're going to experience.  Shouldn't that be the same with movies?  I've read Les Misérables and seen the show.  I'm happy both versions exist.

Yes, the book is generally better than the movie if you want to experience the full picture the author was trying to bring to you but that was because it was designed first to be told through the written material and not the movie's brief window of opportunity.  I was warned not to watch 'The Martian' especially if you've read the book.  I had and I did watch the movie, I loved both.  The movie had some scenes missing from the book but it didn't stop me from enjoying it.  Yes, there were some scenarios that made more sense in the book because the author could explain what the science behind the scene was about but I still enjoyed the two hours of Martian life on my TV with an epic soundtrack and incredible cinematography.

Enjoy the books and the movie versions of those books.  There's no reason why we can't enjoy both.  Now video game movie tie-ins.   Don't get me started on those.

Hope you all enjoy Ready Player One.

Rob Wainfur

The Bearded Trio - The Site For Steven Spielberg, George Lucas, John Williams and a whole lot more.

Popular posts from this blog

Did Paul Freeman Accidentally Eat A Fly In Raiders of the Lost Ark?

The Famous Indiana Jones Fly In Belloq's Mouth Scene.  Did It Really Happen? I've always wondered if Paul Freeman unintentionally consumed a fly in this scene in  Raiders of the Lost Ark ?  It's the scene where Indiana Jones shouts down to Bellosh...I mean Belloq and threatens to blow up the ark.  Did a fly go in his mouth? I remember watching this scene back in the early eighties and my ten year old mind thought he definitely had a snack while filming.  I recall talking about 'flygate' in my school playground at the time and the general consensus with my friends was that Freeman definitely had a sneaky snack. Paul Freeman talks about the famous 'fly' scene in an interview with  and settled 'flygate:' This is a bit of a dicey question so don’t get too upset. (Laughs) A movie’s always got bloopers in it, some have a lot, and some only have three or four. And the most remarkable blooper was right before the opening of th

Star Wars VII Movie Poster - Every End Is A New Beginning

Star Wars VII Movie Poster Just saw this Star Wars VII movie poster on Kyle Newman's Facebook fee d.  The poster is by  Lyndon Berresford and Paul Bateman.  I am loving this.  Who do you think the two characters are?  Lando and Leia?  Han and Leia's children? Have you seen other Star Wars VII movie posters?  Let me know. Rob Wainfur @welshslider

Explaining That "Weird" Cut In Poltergeist. Read The Missing Scene

Why Is There A Strange Cut In The 1982 Horror Classic, Poltergeist? If you're a fan of the 1982 Horror classic, Poltergeist then you will be very familiar with that "weird" cut in the movie.  It's 32 minutes and 47 seconds in to the movie and the scene is where Diane is explaining the strange phenomenon that is happening in the kitchen.  First, she shows to Steve a chair scraping across the floor all on its own then she does the same with Carol Anne.  Steve leans up against the kitchen wall and is completely shocked at what just happened.  It's at this point Diane starts to explain the sensation of being pulled and then...A very abrupt cut.  One moment we are listening to Diane and suddenly it cuts to Diane and Steve at their next door neighbours door.  Why the sudden cut?  It's on the VHS, DVD, Blu-Ray and even the streaming versions.  Why does this awful and weird cut exist in the movie, Poltergeist?  Watch the clip below to see the cut: Well, the ans